Animal Comparisons

Turtle vs Tortoise: Shells, Feet and Why Habitat Decides

Every tortoise is a turtle. Tortoises live on land with domed shells and stumpy feet, while most other turtles have flatter shells and webbed feet or flippers.

Two tortoises on a light brown background

People use "turtle" and "tortoise" as if they were two separate animals. Scientifically, they aren't. Every tortoise belongs to the turtle order, Testudines, so a tortoise is a turtle the way a poodle is a dog.

What splits them is where they live. Tortoises stay on dry land, and most other turtles swim. That one fact explains nearly every difference you can see, from the shape of the shell to the shape of the toes.

Quick facts

  • The San Diego Zoo counts 328 modern turtle species in 13 families, tortoises included (San Diego Zoo).

  • Britannica lists about 49 tortoise species in at least 15 living genera, all in the family Testudinidae (Britannica).

  • Turtles and tortoises date back about 220 million years (San Diego Zoo).

  • A turtle shell is made of 59 to 61 bones covered by keratin plates called scutes (San Diego Zoo).

  • Jonathan, a Seychelles giant tortoise on Saint Helena, hatched in the early 1830s and is called the oldest known land animal (Britannica).

At a glance

  • Habitat: tortoises live only on land; most turtles live in or near water.

  • Shell: tortoises have high, domed shells; water turtles have flatter, smoother ones.

  • Feet: tortoises have stumpy, column-like back legs; turtles have webbed feet or flippers.

  • Diet: tortoises mostly eat plants; many other turtles are omnivores.

  • Lifespan: some land tortoises pass 150 years; the zoo gives about 70 for aquatic species.

  • Classification: all tortoises sit in one family, Testudinidae; "turtle" covers the whole order.

Turtle vs tortoise: is a tortoise a turtle?

Yes. A tortoise is a turtle that has given up life in the water.

Britannica explains that all tortoises belong to the turtle order, Testudines (also called Chelonia). Within that order, tortoises form a single family, Testudinidae. The other turtle families include sea turtles, snapping turtles, softshells, pond turtles and many more.

So calling a tortoise a turtle is correct. Calling a sea turtle a tortoise is wrong, because a sea turtle doesn't belong to the tortoise family.

Some land-living turtles still aren't tortoises. The eastern box turtle spends most of its time on land, yet the Smithsonian's National Zoo places it in a different family, Emydidae. It's more closely related to pond turtles than to tortoises.

How can you tell a turtle from a tortoise by its feet?

Look at the back legs first. A tortoise's back legs are thick and round, like an elephant's, while a water turtle has webbed feet or flippers.

Britannica calls tortoise hind limbs "elephantine" or columnar. Their front legs aren't shaped like flippers, and their back feet have no webbing. Each toe also has two or fewer small bones (phalanges), which makes the foot short and sturdy.

The Nashville Zoo describes tortoise front limbs as club-like and the back legs as pillar-like. Turtles, by contrast, have flipper-like legs or webbed feet.

Why the difference? A heavy animal walking over sand and rock needs posts to stand on. A swimming animal needs paddles. Sea turtles take this furthest. NOAA Fisheries describes their streamlined bodies and large flippers as well suited to the ocean.

Some tortoises use their front legs as tools, too. The US Fish and Wildlife Service says the Mojave desert tortoise has flattened front legs built for digging burrows.

Why are tortoise shells domed?

Tortoises carry tall, rounded shells, and water turtles carry lower, smoother ones. The shape follows the job.

The Nashville Zoo sums it up: tortoises have rounded, domed shells, and turtles have thinner shells shaped for moving through water. Britannica notes that tortoise shells are high domed, with one odd exception, the flat pancake tortoise.

Underneath, the two shells are built the same way. The top half is the carapace and the bottom half is the plastron. According to the San Diego Zoo, the shell is fused to the spine and rib cage, so no turtle or tortoise can climb out of it. The zoo adds that turtles can feel pressure and pain through their shells.

Do turtles and tortoises eat the same things?

No. Tortoises mostly eat plants, while many other turtles eat both plants and animals.

Britannica says most tortoises are vegetarians that eat leaves, flowers and fruit. Forest-dwelling species will sometimes take animal food when they find it. The San Diego Zoo describes tortoises eating low-growing shrubs, grasses and even cactus.

The Galápagos giant tortoise is a good example. The San Diego Zoo says prickly pear cactus is a favorite, along with flowers, leaves and grasses. These tortoises can go up to a year without eating or drinking.

Water turtles have a wider menu. Most are omnivores, and a few are specialists. Leatherback and hawksbill sea turtles, for instance, eat jellyfish. None of them have teeth. They bite with a hard, sharp-edged beak instead. For a full rundown of diets, see our guide to what turtles eat.

Do tortoises live longer than turtles?

Often, yes. The longest-lived species in the group are land tortoises.

The San Diego Zoo gives a lifespan of up to 150 years or more for some land tortoises and about 70 years for aquatic turtles. Jonathan, the famous Seychelles giant tortoise on Saint Helena, hatched in the early 1830s.

Lifespans vary widely by species, though. The zoo says Galápagos tortoises live about 35 years on average, with some living far longer. One named Speed reached about 150. The Fish and Wildlife Service puts Mojave desert tortoises at roughly 50 to 80 years. On the turtle side, the National Zoo says eastern box turtles usually live 25 to 35 years and have survived past 100.

Slow growth comes with long life. Mojave desert tortoises take 13 to 20 years to reach breeding age, which makes it hard for their numbers to bounce back.

Where do turtles and tortoises live?

Turtles live in oceans, rivers, lakes and ponds around the world, while tortoises live on land on every continent except Australia and Antarctica.

Britannica says tortoise habitats range from deserts to wet tropical forests. Desert species spend much of their time underground. The Fish and Wildlife Service says the Mojave desert tortoise spends up to 95% of its life in burrows and hibernates for up to nine months a year.

Even the most aquatic turtles return to land for one reason: eggs. NOAA Fisheries notes that sea turtles spend most of their lives at sea, but adult females lay their eggs on beaches. Some travel thousands of miles between feeding grounds and nesting sites.

What is a terrapin?

A terrapin is a turtle that splits its time between land and water and always stays near water.

The San Diego Zoo uses three working definitions. A turtle spends most of its life in water. A tortoise is a land-dweller. A terrapin lives on both land and water, usually close to the edge. "Terrapin" is a common name rather than a scientific family, so you'll hear it used loosely.

If you enjoy look-alike pairs, try alligator vs crocodile for another reptile mix-up, or why lizards do push-ups for some odd reptile behavior. You'll find more pairs under animal comparisons.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between a turtle and a tortoise?

The main difference between a turtle and a tortoise is habitat. Tortoises live only on land and have domed shells and stumpy, elephant-like legs, while most turtles live in water and have flatter shells with webbed feet or flippers.

Can tortoises swim?

Tortoises are land animals and lack the features water turtles use to swim. Britannica notes that tortoise front legs are not flipper-like and their back feet are not webbed.

Is a tortoise a turtle or a reptile?

A tortoise is both a turtle and a reptile. Tortoises belong to the turtle order, Testudines, which is a group of reptiles, and they make up one family within it, Testudinidae.

Is a box turtle a tortoise?

A box turtle is not a tortoise, even though box turtles live mostly on land. The Smithsonian's National Zoo places box turtles in the family Emydidae, which is separate from the tortoise family.

Which lives longer, a turtle or a tortoise?

Tortoises usually live longer than water turtles. The San Diego Zoo says some land tortoises live 150 years or more, compared with about 70 years for aquatic turtles.

Can a turtle or tortoise live without its shell?

No turtle or tortoise can live without its shell. The shell is fused to the animal's spine and rib cage, so it is part of the skeleton and cannot come off.

Sources

Comments

Leave a comment

Comments are checked before they appear. Please keep it kind and on topic.

Animal Comparisons

Frog vs Toad: Why Every Toad Is Actually a Frog

Toads are a kind of frog. Frogs usually have smooth, moist skin and long jumping legs, while toads have dry, warty skin, short legs and poison glands behind the eyes.

7 min read