Animal Comparisons

Elk vs Moose: Why the Bigger Deer Lives Alone

Moose are the largest deer, with flat, wide antlers and a dangling bell. Elk are smaller, paler grazers with branching antlers that live in herds.

Brown moose on brown grass during daytime

Elk vs moose confusion is easy to forgive. Both are big, brown members of the deer family, and both live in the mountains and forests of the northern US and Canada. In some places, such as Yellowstone, you can find them in the same park.

Names make it worse. In North America, elk means one animal, but in Europe the same word means a moose. Below we sort out the names, the bodies and the reasons each animal lives the way it does.

Quick facts

  • Moose are the largest members of the deer family, standing about six feet tall at the shoulder (National Wildlife Federation).

  • Adult moose in Alaska range from about 800 pounds for a small cow to 1,600 pounds for a large bull (Alaska Department of Fish and Game).

  • Bull elk in Yellowstone weigh about 700 pounds and stand about five feet at the shoulder (National Park Service, Yellowstone).

  • The elk's other name, wapiti, comes from a Shawnee word meaning "white deer" or "white-rumped deer" (NPS, Yellowstone).

  • A big bull moose can grow an 80-pound set of antlers in one summer (Alaska Department of Fish and Game).

What's the difference between an elk and a moose?

An elk and a moose are separate species, and the moose is much bigger and darker. Elk are Cervus canadensis, according to Yellowstone National Park. The moose is Alces alces, which the National Wildlife Federation (NWF) lists as Alces americanus for the North American form.

At a glance

  • Size: Moose are taller and heavier. Bulls can pass 1,000 pounds, while bull elk usually weigh 700 to 1,000.

  • Antlers: Moose antlers are flat and wide like an open hand. Elk antlers are long beams with many pointed tines.

  • Color: Moose are dark brown to nearly black all over. Elk are lighter tan with a darker, shaggy neck and a pale rump.

  • Face: Moose have a big, bulbous nose and a flap of skin called a bell hanging from the throat. Elk have a slimmer, deer-like face.

  • Social life: Moose live alone or in small family groups. Elk travel in herds that can number a few hundred.

  • Voice: Bull elk bugle with a loud, high squeal. Moose make lower grunts and wailing calls.

  • Food: Elk mostly graze grasses, while moose browse willow twigs, leaves and water plants.

These points come from the NWF Blog, Denali National Park, Rocky Mountain National Park and Yellowstone.

Why do Europeans call a moose an elk?

In Europe, the word elk refers to the animal North Americans call a moose. The Alaska Department of Fish and Game says it plainly: the moose is "called elk in Europe."

That's why the North American animal often goes by its other name, wapiti, which avoids the mix-up. Rocky Mountain National Park notes that the animal was originally called wapiti. Yellowstone traces the word to a Shawnee term meaning "white deer" or "white-rumped deer," a nod to the elk's pale rear end.

Elk vs moose size: which is bigger?

The moose is bigger, and by a wide margin. It's the largest deer alive.

Here's how the numbers compare across park and state sources:

  • Moose bulls in Denali weigh 900 to 1,400 pounds, and cows weigh 700 to 1,100, standing 5 to 6.5 feet at the shoulder.

  • Yellowstone's moose belong to the smallest North American subspecies, Alces alces shirasi. Bulls there reach close to 1,000 pounds.

  • Elk bulls in Rocky Mountain National Park weigh 700 to 1,000 pounds and stand about five feet at the shoulder. Cows weigh 300 to 500 pounds.

Moose stand tall partly because of their legs. Denali's rangers describe them as extremely long, which lets moose wade into lakes and reach food buried in deep snow. An elk is still a huge animal, about eight feet long from nose to tail, but next to a moose it looks lean.

How are elk and moose antlers different?

Moose antlers are flat and broad, while elk antlers are long and branching. That's the quickest way to tell bulls apart, even from far away.

Moose antlers

Denali National Park describes a moose antler as curving up and back with a flattened area like the palm of your hand. Prime bulls in Yellowstone grow antlers up to five feet wide from tip to tip, and the NWF says some reach six feet.

The growth rate is startling. The Alaska Department of Fish and Game calls antlers the fastest growing tissue of any mammal. A big bull can build an 80-pound rack over one summer. Moose shed their antlers from late December to late January, Yellowstone says.

Elk antlers

Elk antlers sweep back from the head in two long beams with points along them. A healthy Yellowstone bull's antlers measure 55 to 60 inches long, just under six feet wide, and weigh about 30 pounds a pair. Rocky Mountain National Park says a mature bull's set can weigh up to 40 pounds.

Mature bull elk keep their antlers longer than moose do and shed them in March and April. While antlers grow, they're covered in soft, fuzzy skin called velvet, which bulls rub off by early August.

Why does a moose live alone while elk form herds?

Moose spend most of their lives alone, while elk gather in herds. Food is a big part of the reason.

Elk are grazers. Rocky Mountain National Park says they mainly eat grasses and forbs (soft, broad-leaved plants) and get through about 20 pounds of vegetation a day. Grass grows in wide-open meadows, so many elk can feed together. Herds can grow to a few hundred animals, and more eyes help a herd watch for predators.

Moose are browsers. They nip leaves and twigs from shrubs and trees such as willow, aspen and balsam fir, per the NWF. Yellowstone says moose favor willow flats and forests, and in summer they eat water plants like water lilies and duckweed. That food is patchy and spread out along streams and ponds. A lone moose can work a stand of willows without competition. Yellowstone notes moose are usually alone or in small family groups.

The park pages don't name one single cause, but their descriptions line up: open grass for the herd animal, scattered shrubs for the loner. You can read more about how other deer feed in our post on what deer eat.

Moose vs elk behavior: bugles, swimming and the rut

Elk are loud and social in fall, while moose are quieter swimmers that live near water. Both mate in autumn.

Bugling elk

The elk rut, or mating season, runs from early September to mid-October in Yellowstone. Bulls bugle to show females they're available and fit. Rocky Mountain National Park describes the call as deep tones that rise into a high squeal, then drop into grunts. Prime bulls eight to nine years old have the best chance of mating there.

Swimming moose

Moose are strong swimmers. The NWF says they can hold their breath underwater for 30 seconds while feeding. Alaska's wildlife agency reports that moose apparently swim the six miles across Clarence Strait in Southeast Alaska. In deep winter snow, Denali's moose trample paths called yards as they paw for food.

Are moose or elk more dangerous?

Both animals can hurt people, and you should keep your distance from either one. Denali National Park says moose are big, fast animals that turn aggressive when disturbed, and bulls in the rut can be extremely dangerous. The NWF says a moose can run over 35 miles per hour.

Elk deserve the same respect. Rocky Mountain National Park asks visitors to stay at least 75 feet away, or about two bus lengths.

Where do elk and moose live?

Moose live in colder, wetter northern forests, while elk range across the Rocky Mountain region and other western areas. The NWF Blog places moose in northern New England, the Northern Rockies and Alaska. The NWF wildlife guide adds Canada and a band of northern states from Maine to Washington, always near forests, streams and ponds.

Elk once faced near extinction. Rocky Mountain National Park says hunting nearly wiped them out by 1890, and 49 elk from Yellowstone were moved there in 1913 and 1914 to restart the herd. Yellowstone now holds 10,000 to 20,000 elk in summer. It has fewer than 200 moose.

Like it here? Compare other look-alike wildlife in bison vs buffalo, coyote vs wolf and alligator vs crocodile, or browse the full animal comparisons category.

Frequently asked questions

Is a moose bigger than an elk?

Yes, a moose is bigger than an elk. Denali National Park lists bull moose at 900 to 1,400 pounds, while Rocky Mountain National Park gives bull elk 700 to 1,000 pounds.

Are elk and moose the same animal?

No, elk and moose are different species in the deer family. The confusion comes from Europe, where the word elk is used for the animal North Americans call a moose.

How can you tell a moose from an elk?

The easiest way to tell a moose from an elk is the antlers and nose. A moose has flat, hand-shaped antlers, a bulbous nose and a bell of skin under its throat. An elk has branching, pointed antlers and a pale rump.

What is a moose called in Europe?

A moose is called an elk in Europe. The Alaska Department of Fish and Game notes this naming difference, which is why North American elk are often called wapiti instead.

Do elk and moose live in the same places?

Elk and moose sometimes share the same parks, such as Yellowstone. Moose stick to willow flats, forests and wet areas, while elk graze in open meadows and move in herds.

How heavy are moose antlers compared to elk antlers?

Moose antlers are heavier than elk antlers. A big bull moose can grow an 80-pound rack, per Alaska's wildlife agency, while a Yellowstone bull elk's antlers weigh about 30 pounds a pair.

Sources

  • Moose, National Park Service, Yellowstone National Park

  • Elk, National Park Service, Yellowstone National Park

  • Elk, National Park Service, Rocky Mountain National Park

  • Moose, National Park Service, Denali National Park and Preserve

  • Moose species profile, Alaska Department of Fish and Game

  • Moose, National Wildlife Federation

  • Are these elk, moose or caribou?, National Wildlife Federation Blog

Comments

Leave a comment

Comments are checked before they appear. Please keep it kind and on topic.

Animal Comparisons

Frog vs Toad: Why Every Toad Is Actually a Frog

Toads are a kind of frog. Frogs usually have smooth, moist skin and long jumping legs, while toads have dry, warty skin, short legs and poison glands behind the eyes.

7 min read