Ocean & Aquatic Life

Do Fish Feel Pain? What the Science Says, and Where It Splits

Fish have pain-detecting nerves, and injured fish change their behavior in ways painkillers reverse. Many researchers think fish feel pain, though some scientists argue fish brains can't produce it.

Shoal of fish swimming underwater

Fish don't scream or limp, so it's easy to assume they feel nothing. So do fish feel pain, or is a hooked fish just reacting on autopilot?

The question turns out to be harder than it sounds. Nobody can ask a fish how it feels. Scientists have to look at nerves, brains and behavior, and then argue about what the evidence means. Here's what the main studies found and where the disagreement lies.

Quick facts

  • In 2003 Lynne Sneddon, Victoria Braithwaite and Michael Gentle found nociceptors on the heads of rainbow trout, reported in Proceedings of the Royal Society B.

  • Those receptors responded to pressure, heat above 40°C (104°F) and acetic acid, the acid in vinegar.

  • The trout study identified 22 nociceptors among 58 receptors on the face and head, according to a summary of the research on Wikipedia's pain in fish page.

  • Brian Key of the University of Queensland argued in a 2016 Animal Sentience paper that fish brains can't produce felt pain. It drew 46 published responses.

  • Biologist Victoria Braithwaite set out the case for fish pain in her 2010 Oxford University Press book Do Fish Feel Pain?, cited by RSPCA Australia.

What's the difference between nociception and pain?

Nociception is the detection of something that damages tissue, while pain is the unpleasant feeling that can come with it. The 2003 trout paper drew this line in its first sentences. Nociception can trigger a simple reflex, like pulling a hand off a hot stove before you notice it hurts.

Pain is the conscious experience on top of that reflex. It's the part that makes an animal guard an injury, avoid the place it got hurt and act differently for hours. When scientists ask "do fish feel pain," they mostly agree fish have nociception. The argument is about whether fish also have the feeling.

Do fish have pain receptors?

Yes, fish have pain receptors. Sneddon and her colleagues showed this in rainbow trout in 2003, and their paper was titled with the question "Do fishes have nociceptors?"

The team recorded from nerves in the trout's head. They found polymodal nociceptors, meaning receptors that respond to more than one kind of harm. These fired in response to:

  • Mechanical pressure

  • Heat above 40°C

  • Acetic acid

Most of these trout receptors were A-delta fibers, a type of nerve fiber. The authors noted this pattern differs from what's seen in mammals and birds. Their paper's subtitle framed the find as evidence for how this sensory system evolved in vertebrates.

How do fish react to pain?

Fish react to painful injuries with changes that last longer than a reflex. In the same 2003 study, trout injected in the lips with acetic acid or bee venom breathed faster, measured by how quickly their gill covers beat. They also took longer to start eating again.

The fish also showed what the authors called anomalous behaviors. Summaries of the work describe trout rocking from side to side and rubbing their lips against the gravel and tank walls. Rubbing a sore spot is the kind of thing a person does with a stubbed toe.

The authors argued these changes point to prolonged discomfort. A fish that only flinched would go back to normal right away. These fish didn't.

Do painkillers work on fish?

Yes, painkillers seem to work on fish, which is some of the strongest evidence for fish pain. In a follow-up study described on Wikipedia's pain in fish page, Sneddon gave trout morphine before the acid injection. The morphine reduced the rocking, rubbing and fast breathing, and bigger doses had bigger effects.

Zebrafish experiments point the same way. Zebrafish given a choice prefer an enriched tank area, one with things to explore, over a bare one. After a painful acid injection, though, the fish spent more than half their time in the bare area when it had painkiller dissolved in the water. They gave up something they liked in order to get relief.

Why do some scientists say fish can't feel pain?

Some scientists argue fish lack the brain structures needed to feel pain consciously. James Rose of the University of Wyoming made this case in 2002. He pointed out that fish have no neocortex, the wrinkled outer layer of the brain linked to conscious experience in humans.

Brian Key, a neuroscientist at the University of Queensland, took a similar line in 2016. His paper in the journal Animal Sentience was titled "Why fish do not feel pain." Key argued that fish lack the brain cell layout, circuitry and connections needed to process pain as a feeling. His reasoning rests on the idea that structure determines function.

Both researchers accept that fish detect damage. Their point is that detecting damage isn't the same as suffering, and they say some studies blur the two.

Do most scientists think fish feel pain?

There's no formal vote, and no study can prove what a fish feels. But the skeptical view has drawn heavy pushback. Key's 2016 paper drew 46 commentaries, including responses from Braithwaite and Sneddon that challenged his reasoning.

In 2018 Sneddon and nine co-authors answered the skeptics in a paper called "Fish sentience denial: Muddying the waters," also in Animal Sentience. They argued that the experimental record shows fish have the capacity for nociception and pain, and deserve welfare protection. They also criticized skeptics for rejecting the precautionary principle, the idea of acting carefully when harm is likely but not proven.

The 2003 trout paper started from a related point. Pain perception had already been shown in birds and mammals, the authors wrote, but hadn't been studied systematically in fish and other so-called lower vertebrates.

Do fish feel pain when hooked?

Probably, based on the trout and zebrafish evidence, though no one can measure exactly what a hooked fish feels. The lips of rainbow trout are where Sneddon's team found nociceptors and where they injected acid. A hook goes through much the same tissue.

Concern about angling comes from both scientists and animal welfare groups. RSPCA Australia says the evidence that fish are sentient animals capable of pain and suffering has been building for years. It recommends:

  1. Catching fewer fish

  2. Reducing suffering during capture

  3. Killing landed fish quickly and humanely

  4. Not using live bait

If you keep fish at home, the same evidence is a reason to handle them gently and watch for signs of injury. For other fish questions, read do fish get thirsty or our ocean life section. And if you like odd animal anatomy, see how many hearts an octopus has.

Frequently asked questions

Do fish feel pain?

Fish very likely feel pain, based on studies of rainbow trout and zebrafish. Fish have pain receptors, react to injury for long periods and respond to painkillers, though a few scientists argue fish brains can't consciously feel pain.

Do fish have pain receptors?

Yes, fish have pain receptors called nociceptors. A 2003 study found nociceptors on the heads of rainbow trout that responded to pressure, heat above 40°C and acetic acid.

Do fish feel pain when hooked?

Fish probably feel pain when hooked. Rainbow trout have nociceptors in their lips, and trout injected in the lips with acid rubbed the area and stopped eating for a while.

Can fish feel pain without a neocortex?

Some scientists, including James Rose and Brian Key, argue fish can't feel pain because fish lack a neocortex and related brain wiring. Lynne Sneddon and other researchers reply that experiments on nociception and painkillers show fish have the capacity for pain.

Do painkillers work on fish?

Painkillers appear to work on fish. Morphine reduced pain-related behavior in injured rainbow trout, and zebrafish in pain chose to stay in a bare tank area when painkiller was dissolved in the water there.

Do fish feel pain like humans?

Fish pain probably isn't identical to human pain, because fish brains are built differently. Fish do have pain receptors and show long-lasting pain behaviors, so groups like RSPCA Australia treat fish as able to suffer.

Sources

Comments

Leave a comment

Comments are checked before they appear. Please keep it kind and on topic.